Omo-Agege: Abuse of court process

By Mod2   1 week ago   149
Opinion / Stories - Top Stories

By Richard Akinnola 

Omo-Agege

 Ovie Omo-Agege

Expounding of the issue of forum shopping, which is regarded as an abuse of Court process, the Supreme court, per Chukwuma-Eneh, JSC stated as follows: “The term abuse of process connotes simply the misuse of Court’s process and it includes acts which otherwise interfere with the course of justice. Clearly, the acts include where without reasonable.

ground a party institutes frivolous, vexatious and oppressive actions and also by instituting of multiplicity of actions or is on a frolic act of forum-shopping i.e. seeking  favourable Court to entertain a matter. It also includes depriving the court of jurisdiction. Arising from such acts the Court has the power to treat the acts as contemptuous of the Court which can apart from resorting to the use of its coercive powers of contempt can also order the action to be stayed (as has been done here in the appeal No. CA/S/EP/GV/10/2009 or dismiss it as the case may be.” – See Alhaji Muhammadu Maigari Dingyadi & anor. v. Independent National Electoral Commission & 2 Ors (No.2) (2010) 18 NWLR (Pt. 1224) 154 at 195.

The Supreme court in a number of cases, has often frowned at the flagrant abuse of court processes, particularly on similar matters that had been previously litigated.

It is against this backdrop that l view the recent suit filed at the Federal High court, Abuja by an amorphous group called the Incorporated trustees of Empowerment  for unemployed Youths Initiative, seeking  an order for the withdrawal of certificate of return issued to the Deputy Senate president, Senator Ovie Omo-Agege.

In the suit, the claimant is claiming that the deputy Senate president “is not a fit and proper person”  to be so elected, having been allegedly convicted by a Los Angeles, California State Bar court on November 30, 1995.

The claimant further averred that Omo-Agege was allegedly sentenced to jail terms and suspended from law practice for two years for alleged felony.

Curiously, the gravamen of these claims have been previously pooh-poohed by another Abuja court as being patently false.

On January 30, this year, an Abuja High court had stated that there was no evidence that Senator Omo-Agege was convicted in the United States.

The Federal Capital Territory (FCT) High Court sitting in Bwari had dismissed a suit seeking the removal of Senator Ovie Omo-Agege as deputy senate president.

As reported in the Vanguard of January 30, 2020, the suit  by the Incorporated Trustees of Patriotic Youth Organisation of Nigeria, had asked the court to void Omo-Agege’s election on the grounds that he submitted false information to the Independent National Electoral Commission, INEC.

The group alleged that the deputy Senate president committed perjury when he denied been convicted by any court of law in the United States of America, the subject matter of this new suit.

But in his judgment,  Justice Othman Musa, held that the defendant was not guilty of perjury as alleged by the claimants.

The judge said the case against the Senator in the US was a non-criminal trial by a judicial commission of inquiry in California, which did not amount to a conviction.

He added that since Omo-Agege challenged the case at the US Supreme Court and won, he was not obligated to disclose such information to INEC before contesting an election.

In dismissing the suit, the court awarded N1 million as costs against the claimant.

Interestingly, it’s on this same subject matter that had been litigated upon, that this new group is similarly asking the court to adjudicate, a move which amounts to a flagrant abuse of court process.

This has often been frowned at by the Supreme court in a plethora of cases.

In  Lokpobiri v. Ogola(2016) 3 NWLR (pt. 1499) 328 at 367- 388 paras E-F; Ladejo v. Ajimobi (2016) 10 NWLR (PT. 1519) 88 at 128 paras A-B, the court held that where a court comes to the conclusion that its process is being abused, the appropriate order to make is that of dismissal of the process.

Without prejudice to the merit or otherwise of the present matter, it is important to respect the sanctity of our judiciary by not exposing it to ridicule with multiplicity of cases on same subject matter that had been previously litigated.

In the case of PDP v. Sheriff (2017) 15 NWLR (PT. 1588) 219 at 265-266 paras D-G, the Supreme court court held thus:

“….the basis of the rule on abuse of court process is the real possibility of two conflicting decisions in respect on one and the same subject matter. So, it is desirable that the issues common to both parties are heard and determined in only one court”.

It is my considered view that since the subject matter of this new suit had been litigated upon and judgement delivered, it amounts to an abuse of court process to again subject the court on another tortuous journey, in the same court of coordinate jurisdiction.

[NewsNaira]



Share this article!



Login to comment and earn


Prince Ben
1 week ago

Violators of court process should be penalized


(Quote) (Likes)

The order of the day


(Quote) (Likes)
Hussaina Adamu
1 week ago

Think deeply about it first


(Quote) (Likes)

Grace upon God pple 


(Quote) (Likes)
Abiola Ojewola
1 week ago

They are above the law of the Country


(Quote) (Likes)

OK no problem 


(Quote) (Likes)
Emmanuel Jille
1 week ago

Court disobedience can csuse arnachy


(Quote) (Likes)

It very good update


(Quote) (Likes)
Chibundu
1 week ago

Still talking about dis issue


(Quote) (Likes)
Bisayo Olumide
1 week ago

What an insult 


(Quote) (Likes)

Agege oinn hwmac


(Quote) (Likes)

Na their cup of tea 


(Quote) (Likes)

It is not good at all


(Quote) (Likes)
Unegbu Bright
1 week ago

Order of the day 


(Quote) (Likes)
Eze Andrew
1 week ago

The man is wax strong politically. Since national assembly show down


(Quote) (Likes)
Junior
1 week ago

That's not good at all 


(Quote) (Likes)
Isaac Segun
1 week ago

He must pay for his actions


(Quote) (Likes)

Abused nation. Abused everything 


(Quote) (Likes)

He said he so he an so he St


(Quote) (Likes)
Chimere
1 week ago

It's been like that for decades


(Quote) (Likes)


What is News₦aira Income Program(News₦IP)

  • News₦aira Income Program (News₦IP) is a system aimed at raising revenue for registered users that browse the NewsNaira Website. An online program driven by a goal of solving the financial problems among the youths, students, middle class and whoever wishes to take advantage of earning opportunity and making money online legitimately in Nigeria as it creates the channel for participants to earn residual income on weekly basis.
more

How News₦IP Works

  • News₦aira has 2 means of generating income for our members.
    News₦AP: NewsNaira Affiliate Program - With News₦AP, participants earns ₦1,000 whenever they refer anyone to join NewsNaira Income Program. There is no limit to how many people you can refer.

    News₦ARS: NewsNaira Ad Revenue Sharing - With News₦ARS, participants earns residual income bonus by reading news, commentting on articles, publishing forum posts, daily login to their NewsNaira account, and even sharing assigned sponsored post on social media.

    We share our ads revenue with you weekly when you make NewsNaira community your news and information household.
more